Project

General

Profile

Feature #1766

Verifying the scifi CDB geometry

Added by Dobbs, Adam about 8 years ago. Updated almost 8 years ago.

Status:
Open
Priority:
Normal
Assignee:
Kyberd, Paul
Category:
Geometry
Target version:
MAUS-v1.1.1
Start date:
01 October 2015
Due date:
% Done:

0%

Estimated time:
Workflow:
New Issue

Description

I have been looking at the new scifi geometry in the preprod cdb, using run file 07157.000 and MAUS 1.1.0. It be reproduced with:

python bin/utilities/download_geometry.py --cdb_download_url="http://preprodcdb.mice.rl.ac.uk/cdb/" --geometry_download_by="id" --geometry_download_id=671

python bin/analyze_data_offline.py --simulation_geometry_file files/geometry/download/ParentGeometryFile.dat --daq_data_path /home/adobbs/MAUS/data/07157/ --daq_data_file 07157.000
mv maus_output.root maus_output_preprod_07157-000.root

python bin/analyze_data_offline.py --simulation_geometry_file "Stage4.dat" --daq_data_path /home/adobbs/MAUS/data/07157/ --daq_data_file 07157.000
mv maus_output. maus_output_legacy_07157-000.root

I attached some plots for both the legacy and preprod geometry. The only significant difference I can see is in the event viewer position plots. What do people think?

Files

p-value_preprod.pdf (14.1 KB) p-value_preprod.pdf Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:46
spoint-npe_legacy.pdf (14.1 KB) spoint-npe_legacy.pdf Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:46
spoint-npe_preprod.pdf (14.1 KB) spoint-npe_preprod.pdf Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:46
spoint-x_legacy.pdf (14.2 KB) spoint-x_legacy.pdf Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:46
EventViewerPosition_legacy.png (192 KB) EventViewerPosition_legacy.png Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:46
EventViewerPosition_preprod.png (194 KB) EventViewerPosition_preprod.png Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:46
maus_output_legacy_07157-000.root (59.4 MB) maus_output_legacy_07157-000.root Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:46
maus_output_preprod_07157-000.root (60.1 MB) maus_output_preprod_07157-000.root Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:46
spoint-x_preprod.pdf (14.2 KB) spoint-x_preprod.pdf Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:46
p-value_legacy.pdf (14 KB) p-value_legacy.pdf Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:46
EventViewerMomentum_legacy.png (104 KB) EventViewerMomentum_legacy.png Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:51
EventViewerMomentum_preprod.png (106 KB) EventViewerMomentum_preprod.png Dobbs, Adam, 01 October 2015 16:51
#1

Updated by Dobbs, Adam about 8 years ago

Significant differences in momentum too it seems (attached)

#2

Updated by Dobbs, Adam about 8 years ago

Hmmm, may be re-running with the trunk will help...

#3

Updated by Dobbs, Adam about 8 years ago

Strike that. Just re-run the event viewer with the merge branch - legacy and preprod cdb producing pretty much identical event viewer plots. As far as I am concerned I happy for us to pass the preprod geometry, but I would like another set or two of eyes to confirm.

#4

Updated by Dobbs, Adam almost 8 years ago

Bump. Paul, Chris Heidt, Chris Hunt, could you take a look and give a yay or nay on if you are happy?

Also available in: Atom PDF